A restrictive clause is an essential grammatical unit that limits or identifies the noun it modifies. On the Digital SAT, these clauses appear frequently within the Standard English Conventions questions. Unlike nonrestrictive clauses, they are never set off by commas, a distinction typically tested in approximately 2 to 4 questions per exam.
Restrictive Clause
Quick answer
Restrictive Clause
A restrictive clause, also known as an essential clause, is a dependent clause that provides information necessary to identify the specific noun it follows. It is grammatically integrated into the sentence without the use of commas, often following the relative pronoun 'that'.
On the Digital SAT
This concept is tested in the Reading and Writing section of the Digital SAT, specifically within the 'Standard English Conventions' domain. These questions typically fall under punctuation or sentence structure categories. Students will encounter approximately 2 to 5 items per test that require distinguishing between essential and non-essential information. The SAT specifically asks students to determine if a clause or appositive phrase is necessary to the sentence's meaning; if it is restrictive, no punctuation should separate it from the noun it modifies. Mastery of this concept is vital for correctly answering questions involving 'that' vs. 'which' and for avoiding unnecessary comma usage in complex sentence constructions.
Example
Question: Which sentence is punctuated correctly for the Digital SAT? A) The painting, that was stolen in 1990, has never been found. B) The painting that was stolen in 1990 has never been found. Solution: B is correct. 'That was stolen in 1990' is a restrictive clause because it identifies which specific painting is being discussed. Restrictive clauses do not take commas.
Common mistakes
- 1
Mistake 1: Placing commas around 'that' clauses. Students often mistakenly treat all relative clauses as non-essential, but 'that' almost always introduces a restrictive clause requiring no punctuation.
- 2
Mistake 2: Over-punctuating based on natural pauses. Students may add commas where they would pause while speaking, rather than following the rule that essential information must remain unpunctuated.
- 3
Mistake 3: Misidentifying essential names. Students frequently put commas around names (appositives) that are actually restrictive, such as in 'The director Steven Spielberg,' where the name is necessary to identify which director.
Pro tip
Students targeting 750+ should know that the distinction between restrictive and nonrestrictive often depends on the specificity of the preceding noun. If the noun is already unique (e.g., 'My only sister'), the following clause is nonrestrictive and needs commas; if the noun is general (e.g., 'The sister'), the following clause is likely restrictive and needs no commas.
Related terms
More guides
FAQ
What is Restrictive Clause on the SAT?
A restrictive clause is a group of words essential to the meaning of a sentence because it identifies the specific noun being described. On the Digital SAT, these clauses are tested in the Standard English Conventions section. They are never surrounded by commas. Identifying them correctly allows students to choose the right punctuation for complex sentences, ensuring the intended meaning remains clear and grammatically sound.
How do you identify a Restrictive Clause?
To identify a restrictive clause, try removing it from the sentence. If the sentence's meaning becomes too vague or changes entirely, the clause is restrictive. For example, in 'The students who studied passed,' removing 'who studied' changes the meaning from a specific group to all students. Additionally, look for the relative pronoun 'that,' which almost always signals a restrictive clause that should not have commas.
What is the difference between Restrictive Clause and nonrestrictive-clause?
The primary difference lies in whether the information is essential to the sentence's meaning. A restrictive clause limits the noun and uses no commas. A nonrestrictive clause adds 'bonus' information that can be removed without changing the noun's identity; it must be set off by commas, dashes, or parentheses. On the SAT, choosing between them is a common way to test punctuation mastery.
How many SAT questions test Restrictive Clause?
While the exact number varies by test form, students will typically see approximately 2 to 5 questions that involve restrictive or nonrestrictive elements. These are usually found in the Reading and Writing modules under the Standard English Conventions category. Mastery of this single rule can significantly improve a student's score in the punctuation-heavy portions of the verbal section.
